Feature request: per-mode customization for Plan-mode question clarity (without forking)
What variant of Codex are you using?
CLI + IDE Extension (collaboration modes)
What feature would you like to see?
Today, Plan mode question behavior is mostly controlled by built-in collaboration mode templates.
To enforce consistently clear questions, we currently need to fork Codex or inject overrides from a custom orchestrator.
I’d like a first-class way to customize question style per collaboration mode (especially Plan mode) from user/project config, without patching source.
Use case:
- Before asking a question, Codex should present:
1) context,
2) impact,
3) 2-4 concrete options with tradeoffs + examples,
4) recommended option,
5) one final closed question.
- No implicit auto-advance when user has not explicitly answered (human gate remains required).
Requested capability:
- Allow per-mode instruction override from config (e.g. plan/default), ideally file-based.
- Stable behavior across CLI/App/IDE Extension.
- Should affect both direct clarification questions and request_user_input flows.
- Should not require modifying built-in template files in source.
Why this matters:
AGENTS.md/user instructions are not always sufficient because collaboration-mode developer instructions can take precedence. A supported per-mode override would remove the need for forks and improve UX consistency.
Additional information
Additional information
Related implementation points in repository:
- core/templates/collaboration_mode/plan.md
- core/src/models_manager/collaboration_mode_presets.rs
- app-server turn/start collaboration_mode developer_instructions handling
6 Comments
Hope I can contribute by resolving this issue.
this is a quite simple change imho
hope this will be take in consideration
bump :)
@JayceeB1, we generally prioritize features based on community upvotes. Bumping it won't increase the upvote count. :)
Sorry, was worth a try 🙏🏼
This feature request hasn't received enough upvotes, so I'm closing.